Menu

The First Cause of the Universe Must Be Personal

Philosophers who believe in the biblical God have given powerful arguments to the effect that the Universe itself must be caused. This is a major part of natural theology, or the study of what can be known about God from general revelation in nature. Charles Taliaferro defined natural theology as “the practice of philosophically reflecting on the existence and nature of God independent of real or apparent divine revelation or scripture.”1 Cosmological arguments for God’s existence are based on the existence of the cosmos or on some cosmic feature of it.2 For example, William Lane Craig has advocated for the following simple argument:3

  • Whatever begins to exist has a cause.
  • The Universe began to exist.
  • Therefore, the Universe has a cause.

While this argument does not directly comment on the nature of the uncaused First Cause, nevertheless some attributes of this first cause are implicated by the argument. For example, Craig has pointed out that the past-finitude of the Universe, widely accepted today,4 implies that the First Cause is personal. An impersonal force or substance cannot choose, and thus the personality of the First Cause is required for His choosing to create the Universe:

If a cause is sufficient to produce its effect, then if the cause is there, the effect must be there, too. For example, the cause of water’s freezing is the temperature’s being below 0 degrees Celsius. If the temperature has been below 0 degrees from eternity, then any water around would be frozen from eternity. It would be impossible for the water to begin to freeze just a finite time ago. Now the cause of the universe is permanently there, since it is timeless. So why isn’t the universe permanently there as well?. . .Why isn’t it as permanent as its cause? [T]he answer to this problem is that the First Cause must be a personal being endowed with freedom of the will. His creating the universe is a free act which is independent of any prior determining conditions. So his act of creating can be something spontaneous and new. Freedom of the will enables one to get an effect with a beginning from a permanent, timeless cause. Thus, we are brought not merely to a transcendent cause of the universe but to its Personal Creator.5

Notice that the key point here is that a Personal Creator is required to bring the Universe into existence a finite time ago. If the cause of the Universe were powerful enough to bring a Universe into existence, but impersonal, then the Universe always would have existed.

Sometimes skeptics will suggest that the first cause of the Universe need not be a Personal God, but could instead be some “non-personal timeless stuff.”6 For example, Erik Wielenberg has suggested that a “Cosmic Bomb” had “the potential to transform, uncaused, into whatever existed in the very first moments of the universe, which in turn resulted in the Big Bang.”7 The Cosmic Bomb (and other similar hypotheses about non-personal causes for the Universe) are dissatisfactory because they provide no efficient cause, or explanation as to why the eternally existing stuff would transform into a Universe.8 It is important to distinguish between efficient causes and other kinds of causes.

Different Kinds of Causes

In the fourth century B.C., Aristotle observed that there are four types of causes, or explanations for why anything exists. Andrea Falcon has provided a helpful summary of Aristotle’s four causes, which I adapt here:

  • The material cause or that which is given in reply to the question “What is it made out of?” What is singled out in the answer need not be material objects such as bricks, stones, or planks, but rather constituent parts. (By Aristotle’s lights, A and B are the material cause of the syllable BA.)
  • The formal cause or that which is given in reply to the question “What is it?” What is singled out in the answer is the essence or the what-it-is-to-be something (e.g., a chair, a horse, etc.).
  • The efficient cause or that which is given in reply to the question: “Where does its change (or motion) come from?” What is singled out in the answer is the force that produces the change that brings the thing into being.
  • The final cause is that which is given in reply to the question: “What is its good?” or “What is it for?” What is singled out in the answer is that for the sake of which something is done or takes place.9

The Personal Creator provides us with all four types of causality or explanation for the existence of the temporally finite Universe. The timeless and spaceless God brought into existence the material out of which the Universe is made, provided definition to the formless creation, supplied the power for the creation, and determined the objective meaning of the Universe. Impersonal explanations such as the Cosmic Bomb provide a material cause but lack causality in all other areas. An eternally existing collection of “stuff” would need an external, efficient cause to produce anything else temporally, such as a Universe.

Quantum Fluctuations

We know relatively little about the nature of physical structures at the sub-atomic, or quantum level. Wielenberg, following the ideas of a variety of theorists, suggests that cosmic stuff can produce a Universe, because on the sub-atomic level, virtual particles allegedly arise uncaused. We have responded to this argument elsewhere.10 Briefly, observe that there are several problems with this:11 First, there is uncertainty as to whether these virtual particles exist. Second, many physicists believe that the particles are deterministically caused. Finally, even if we were to accept that the fleeting virtual particles pop into and out of existence, this does not represent a case of something arising from nothing. For, “[T]he vacuum is not nothing but is a sea of fluctuating energy endowed with a rich structure and subject to physical laws.”12 Even if sub-atomic particles do pop briefly into existence in-deterministically in the quantum vacuum, it would not provide evidence that the entire Universe is a quantum fluctuation. And finally, one must ask where the quantum energy came from to begin with.

Conclusion

If it were possible for the stuff to transform into a Universe, then it would have done so from all eternity, and we would not observe a past-finite Universe as we do. Natural theology shows us that a Personal Creator is required for a satisfactory explanation for the Universe as we find it, and the Bible reveals His character.

Endnotes

1 Charles Taliaferro (2012), “The Project of Natural Theology,” in The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology (Malden: Wiley-Blackwell), p. 1. 

2 Alexander Pruss (2012), “The Leibnizian Cosmological Argument,” in The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology (Malden: Wiley-Blackwell), p. 24.

3 William Lane Craig (2015), “The Kalam Cosmological Argument,” Reasonable Faith, https://www.reasonablefaith.org/writings/popular-writings/existence-natureof-god/the-kalam-cosmological-argument.

4 See Jeff Miller (2007), “God and the Laws of Thermodynamics: A Mechanical Engineer’s Perspective,” Reason & Revelation, 27[4]:25-31, https://apologeticspress.org/god-and-the-laws-of-thermodynamics-a-mechanical-engineers-perspective-2106/.

5 Craig (2015), “The Kalam Cosmological Argument.”

6 Erik J. Wielenberg (2026), “Craig’s Kalam Cosmological Argument and the Cosmic Bomb Hypothesis,” Faith and Philosophy, 42[2]:291.

7 Wielenberg, p. 295.

8 William Lane Craig and James D. Sinclair (2012), “The Kalam Cosmological Argument,” in The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology (Malden: Wiley-Blackwell), p. 189, “if coming into being without a material cause seems impossible, coming into being with neither a material nor an efficient cause is doubly absurd.”

9 Andrea Falcon (2023), “Aristotle on Causality,” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-causality/.

10 Jeff Miller (2013), “Can Quantum Mechanics Produce a Universe from Nothing?” Reason & Revelation, 33[2]:14-16,21, https://apologeticspress.org/can-quantum-mechanics-produce-a-universe-from-nothing-4584/.

11 I am summarizing Craig and Sinclair, p. 183.

12 Ibid., p. 183.


Published

A copied sheet of paper

REPRODUCTION & DISCLAIMERS: We are happy to grant permission for this article to be reproduced in part or in its entirety, as long as our stipulations are observed.

Reproduction Stipulations→